Making human rights due diligence a legal requirement for companies including systems to identify, assess, mitigate or manage human rights risks and impacts to improve that process over time and to disclose the risks and impacts, the steps taken and the results.
The entity supports making HRDD a mandatory legal requirement covering identification, prevention, mitigation and remedy of adverse impacts, with disclosure obligations.
The entity states that 'We strongly believe that a mandatory EU Due Diligence legislative framework, combined with a broader 'smart mix of measures', is a necessary and positive step forward.' Also: 'companies should be able to demonstrate that they are taking reasonable steps in identifying, preventing, mitigating, and remedying any actual or potential adverse human rights and environmental impacts.' Finally, 'due diligence should be seen as a continuous, dynamic process of improvement to progressively strengthen and deepen responsible actions - based on ongoing risk-assessments and impact-oriented approaches.'
The entity supports making human rights due diligence a legal requirement, with conditions related to enabling environment.
The paper states that 'ECA believes that an EU Due Diligence Regulation can add value to the functioning of the cocoa supply chain ... However, for it to be meaningful, any EU due diligence system should include a clear strategy to create the above-mentioned enabling environment in cocoa origin countries.' It adds: 'we consider that an EU Due Diligence Regulation applying to all companies that place cocoa or cocoa products on the EU market could be a necessary and positive step forward to a sustainable cocoa supply chain, under the right conditions and with the correct framework.'
The entity welcomes the proposed CSDDD as a legal DD requirement, but frames it as an obligation of means rather than results, and stresses that not all impacts can be prevented despite best efforts.
The entity states that it 'welcomes the proposed Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence.' It adds that 'the Due Diligence framework should be based on an obligation of means, rather than an obligation of results.' Also 'It should also be acknowledged that, despite best efforts, it may not be possible to identify and prevent any and all adverse impacts.'
The entity fully supports an EU-level mandatory due diligence legislation, framing it as an 'obligation of means' with harmonised requirements and a level playing field.
The entity's response to Q2: 'ECA members fully support an EU Due Diligence legislation which is fit for purpose and which can add value to the functioning of the supply chain by creating a level playing field among companies importing into the EU market – notably through harmonized information requirements.' Also (Q15):'Having an EU mandatory Due Diligence legislation would provide much needed legal certainty.'
The entity proactively supports EU-wide mandatory legislation with harmonized requirements to identify, prevent, assess and mitigate adverse impacts, ahead of the formal legislative proposal.
The entity 'fully supports the main targets of the Roadmap for an initiative at EU level on Sustainable Corporate Governance.' In addition, 'an EU-wide legislation on Sustainable Corporate Governance, as opposed to national legislations alone, would bring clear added value, particularly because ... harmonized requirements to identify, prevent, assess and mitigate adverse impacts.' 'In conclusion, ECA strongly supports the EU initiative on Sustainable Corporate Governance.'
Requiring Human rights due diligence of all companies, regardless of sector and size, while still reflecting their individual circumstances..
The entity explicitly calls for DD to apply to all companies regardless of size, sector, or ownership, including non-EU companies operating in the single market.
The paper indicates that 'The Due Diligence requirements should apply to all actors in the supply chain, independently of their size, turnover, operational context, ownership (State-owned enterprises and State entities engaging in public procurement) and not only to companies first placing cocoa and cocoa derived products on the EU market. In addition, the legislation should also apply to non-EU companies placing products or providing services in the single market. ... The Due diligence legislation should be cross-sectorial, covering all commodities and sectors.'
The entity calls for DD to apply to all companies placing cocoa/cocoa products on the EU market, but scope is sector-specific only
It indicates that 'An EU Due Diligence Regulation applying to all companies that place cocoa or cocoa products on the EU market.' Also, 'All requirements foreseen in legislation requiring carrying out due diligence should apply equally to all the actors of the supply chain, namely the cocoa producing countries, the certification schemes, the cocoa and chocolate industry and the retailers.'
The entity strongly calls for DD obligations to apply to all companies regardless of size, including SMEs, and proposes widening the scope to align with CSRD.
The entity 'believes that due diligence should be conducted by all actors in the value chain, regardless of their size, turnover, operational context, ownership ... and not be limited to only a small fraction of EU and non-EU companies operating on the EU market.' It also 'proposes to widen the scope of the Directive by aligning it with the scope of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD).'. Finally, 'for all EU and non-EU companies - including SMEs ... due diligence obligations should apply systematically irrespective of the capacity.'
The entity advocates for ECA advocates for a horizontal approach where due diligence applies to all companies regardless of size, while calling for additional support (not exclusions) for SMEs.
The entity responds to Q16 'Due Diligence legislation should apply to all companies along the supply chain, regardless of size, sector, or turnover. However, we do agree that SMEs will need additional support from the EU, in terms of guidance, funding and sharing of know-how.' Also: 'ECA members support a cross-sector mandatory EU Due Diligence legislation.' (Q15a)
Implementing an enforcement mechanism where companies fail to carry out due diligence as described.
The entity supports enforcement provisions for non-compliance with DD obligations, suggesting to keep liability to process failures and opposing results-based enforcement.
The paper states that 'Member States' competent authorities must be provided with the correct mandate, financial and human resources, and expertise to monitor compliance, investigate if needed.' Also: 'Any enforcement measures should be process-oriented and recognize that even with the most elaborate policies and process in place, economic actors may not be able to prevent all risks and impacts. Consequently, companies should be responsible for failure to establish and maintain an effective Due Diligence process, or for knowingly making false or misleading statements in their reports.'
The entity supports supervision by national authorities with EU coordination as the preferred enforcement mechanism, explicitly stating that legislation without sanctions is ineffective.
The entity's response to Q19: 'ECA members agree that legislation without some sort of sanctions is ineffective. For a mandatory due diligence framework to deliver on its promise, an efficient enforcement mechanism is needed.' It adds: 'We would suggest therefore to opt for supervision by competent national authorities, with a mechanism of EU cooperation and coordination with origin Governments.'
The entity calls for 'more clarity' on enforcement rather than expressing support for a specific or strong enforcement mechanism, which questions feasibility/certainty rather than actively backing enforcement.
The entity states that 'Nonetheless, we believe that more clarity is needed both on enforcement of the rules and on the empowerment of corporate directors who would like to further integrate environmental and human rights interests into business decisions, as stated in the Roadmap.'
Including in the duties of directors and company law obligations to avoid human rights impacts or “harms”.
The entity 'takes note of directors' duties without opposing them, but seeks clarification on how duties apply in group structures and wants remedial efforts to be considered when assessing breaches'.
The entity states that it 'takes note of the directors duties set forth in Article 25 and 26 of the Commission's proposal.' It also points out that it 'would welcome clarification in the Commission's proposal that - in case of a group context - the director duties and liabilities would apply at the level of the holding company rather than joint duties and liabilities of the directors of any individual group company or subsidiary.' Finally, 'the Directive should ensure that when assessing the extent of the breach of directors' duties, the national supervisory authorities take into account the remedial actions taken by the company.'
The entity supports making directors legally responsible for setting up procedures and targets to manage human rights and environmental risks, while also underlining practical limits and the role of origin states
It points out (Q7) that 'We agree that through better planning and internal management, which includes Directors' duties and supervision, companies can improve their environmental performance'. Also, 'We do agree that companies should have in place procedures and targets to identify, prevent and address potential human rights and environmental breaches.' Finally 'Directors should act promptly and manage the risks for the company in relation to their stakeholders' interests.'.
The entity raises the topic of empowering corporate directors to integrate human rights/environmental interests into decisions, but frames it as needing 'more clarity' rather than clearly advocating for or against such duties.
The entity states that 'we believe that more clarity is needed both on enforcement of the rules and on the empowerment of corporate directors who would like to further integrate environmental and human rights interests into business decisions, as stated in the Roadmap.'
Require companies to provide remedy for human rights impacts they have caused or contributed to.
The entity references the need for remedy aligned with UNGPs and calls for grievance mechanisms, recognising companies' responsibility to remedy impacts they caused
The paper points out that 'The need for rights and obligations to be matched to appropriate and effective remedies when breached.' In addition, 'companies are expected to ... implement effective grievance mechanisms.'
The entity agrees that companies should provide remedy/damages to those demonstrably wronged by a company's failure to comply with DD obligations.
The Members of the European Cocoa Association ... agree that there should be a possibility for those who have been demonstrably wronged as a result of a company's failure to comply with its due diligence obligations in Articles 7 and 8 to receive damages.'
Require companies to provide grievance mechanisms for all stakeholders including those in the value chain.
The entity explicitly calls for grievance and complaints mechanisms to be part of the EU DD legislative framework.
It indicates that 'Setting up a harmonized and predictable EU-wide framework (defining the scope, definitions, criteria, transparency requirements, indicators and underlying methodologies, reporting process, verification of actions, grievance and complaints mechanisms) for its implementation by companies and government authorities is highly required.'
ECA supports complaint mechanisms as part of due diligence and considers that they should be promoted at EU level..
The entity responds to question 20c selecting the option that Complaint mechanism as part of due diligence – Should be promoted at EU level'
Enabling judicial enforcement with liability and compensation in case of harm caused by not fulfilling the due diligence obligations.
The entity opposes results-based liability and calls to limit enforcement to process failures, discouraging litigation risk for companies that disclose impacts.
The entity indicates that 'The duty to respect human rights must be distinguished from matters of legal liability and enforcement ... the due diligence legislation should be crafted in a way to incentivize companies to disclose the issues and risks they face along their supply chain, by ensuring that such disclosure will not expose them to an increased risk of litigation. ... Any enforcement measures included in the legislation should focus on proven failures to comply with the due diligence obligations.'
The entity supports civil liability in principle but seeks to condition and narrow it, which would weaken direct judicial enforcement.
The entity states that 'the provisions on civil liability should only be applicable if and to the extent that the competent supervisory authorities in the Member States have established that a company has not complied with its due diligence obligations.' It adds that it 'interprets the Commission's proposal on liability as excluding strict/objective liability and as largely excluding liability for damages caused by indirect business relationships.' It also points out that 'the legislation should ensure that the provisions on civil liability do not expose companies to vexatious litigation.'
The entity does not select judicial enforcement with liability/compensation as an enforcement mechanism and explicitly argues against liability-based enforcement.
In response to question 19a: 'Liability based on complaints and judicial enforcement will not be constructive. This would defeat the very purpose of improving the economic and social conditions of local communities.' The entity selected only 'Supervision by competent national authorities (option 2) with a mechanism of EU cooperation/coordination' in question 19a.
Require companies to implement a due diligence process covering their value chain to identify, prevent, mitigate and remediate human rights impacts and improve that practice over time.
The entity ECA explicitly supports mandatory DD covering the full value chain (upstream and downstream), applying to all actors not just first tier business relationships.
The paper states that 'The Due Diligence requirements should apply to all actors in the supply chain, independently of their size, turnover, operational context.' Also: 'The Due diligence obligations should not be restricted to the first placers (e.g., importer of record) on the EU market but should apply in an equitable fashion throughout the supply chain.' In addition: 'companies should be able to demonstrate that they are taking reasonable steps in identifying, preventing, mitigating, and remedying any actual or potential adverse human rights and environmental impacts based on their own activities or within the operations of those with whom they have a direct business relationship."
The entity supports requiring companies to implement DD processes covering their cocoa supply chain to identify and address human rights and environmental impacts.
The paper indicates that 'ECA member companies, individually and through a multi-stakeholder global approach, have a strong commitment to take actions to monitor, prevent, mitigate and remedy adverse human rights and environmental impacts of their own operations in their supply chains.' Also: 'All requirements foreseen in legislation requiring carrying out due diligence should apply equally to all the actors of the supply chain, namely the cocoa producing countries, the certification schemes, the cocoa and chocolate industry and the retailers.'
The entity supports value chain‑wide, continuous DD processes, and accepts damages for failure to comply with DD obligations.
The entity states that 'due diligence should be seen as a continuous, dynamic process of improvement to progressively strengthen and deepen responsible actions, based on ongoing risk-assessments and impact-oriented approaches, to better prevent and address human rights and environmental harms.' Also, 'due diligence should be conducted by all actors in the value chain.' Finally, the entity agrees 'that there should be a possibility for those who have been demonstrably wronged as a result of a company’s failure to comply with its due diligence obligations in Articles 7 and 8 to receive damages.'
The entity agrees with the due diligence duty definition covering the value chain and supports a cross-sector approach, though emphasises an 'obligation of means' rather than results.
Question 14 'ECA members agree with the definition provided by the EU Commission for the purpose of this consultation.' Also: 'It must be specified in EU legislation that Due Diligence should apply to all actors along the supply chain, including the brands and retailers and not only to the first importer on the EU market.' 'ECA members support a cross-sector mandatory EU Due Diligence legislation.' (Q15a)
The entity references its members' existing commitments to monitor, prevent, mitigate and remedy impacts in their supply chains, and supports EU legislation addressing cross-border supply chains, but the response is centered on direct supply chain rather than full value chain
The response indicates that 'ECA member companies, individually and through a multi-stakeholder approach, ... have a strong commitment to take actions to monitor, prevent, mitigate and remedy adverse human rights and environmental impacts of their own operations in their supply chain.' Also, 'It would not only contribute to companies' capacity to address their cross-border supply chains.'
Require that companies implement contract clauses and Code of Conduct with business partners clarifying obligations to avoid and to address human rights harms.
The entity supports the use of contractual model clauses with business partners, but insists on caution and third-party auditing to avoid a 'box-ticking' exercise.
The entity 'believes that contractual model clauses, when used, should be applied with the utmost care as conducting due diligence must not become a box ticking exercise for companies further away from the origin. For this reason, the European Cocoa Association recommends third-party auditing of these clauses and the validity of the information provided by the supplying party under such a contract.'
Require that companies identify their stakeholders and their interests.
The entity strongly agrees that directors should be required by law to identify the company's stakeholders and their interests.
In response to question 'Identification of the company's stakeholders and their interests: I strongly agree'. 'It is especially important for companies sourcing commodities from developing countries that stakeholders and stakeholder responsibilities are more clearly characterized.' Also, 'we ask the Commission to consider that 'stakeholders' and 'all stakeholders' should be defined, otherwise, the responsibility of companies will be expanded beyond logic'.
Require directors to establish and apply mechanisms or, where they already exist for employees for example, use existing information and consultation channels for engaging with stakeholders.
The entity disagrees to some extent with requiring directors by law to establish mechanisms for stakeholder engagement, arguing it would add unnecessary burden.
In response to question 20a: 'While we fully agree that mandatory Due Diligence ... will lead to better company performance in the long term ... we consider that legislation with too many requirements at Directors level may result in more hurdles for EU companies and it could also decrease attention to core business activities.'
Require that human rights risks and impacts should be assessed through dialogue with stakeholder or with their legitimate representatives.
The entity calls for the extent of stakeholder consultation to be 'strictly defined' via sector-specific guidelines, which could narrow the scope of dialogue-based risk assessment.
The entity states that 'the extent of stakeholder consultation will need to be strictly defined in order for companies to carry out sufficient actions under Articles 6-8 of the proposed Directive.'
Require that corporate directors should manage the human rights risks for the company in relation to stakeholders and their interest including on the long run.
The entity agrees to some extent that corporate directors should be required by law to manage risks in relation to stakeholders' interests on the long run.
In response to Q6: 'Management of the risks for the company in relation to stakeholders and their interests, including on the long run: I agree to some extent.' 'Where the interests of some stakeholders may interfere or pose risks to the fulfilment of duties in respect to the environment and human rights, Directors should act promptly and manage the risks.'
Require companies to set requirements relevant to the prevention of forced or compulsory labour applicable to all workers and all sectors of the economy.
The document elaborates extensively on due diligence expectations for economic operators across the whole cocoa value chain, in line with UNGP/OECD due diligence steps, and does not attempt to narrow the Regulation's scope or definitions.
The document states that 'The European Commission should develop sector-specific guidelines to support both competent authorities and economic operators in framing due diligence expectations in relation to forced labour.' Also, 'To support the implementation of the Regulation, this document aims to clarify what companies operating in the cocoa sector can be expected to do to identify, prevent, mitigate, bring to an end or remediate forced labour.' Later it points out that 'This section describes the measures that companies operating within the cocoa supply chain should be able to take to identify ... bring to an end, or remediate forced labour risks and issues, in accordance with the requirements set out by the EU Forced Labour Regulations for economic operators.'
The entity supports the Regulation's universal scope covering all companies regardless of size/turnover and pushes for legal clarity on the forced child labour definition in line with ILO standards.
The entity states that it 'shares the belief that products verifiably made with forced labour should not be sold on the EU market and therefore agrees with the European Commission's approach of having this Regulation apply to all companies regardless of size or turnover.' In addition, it 'recommends that for legal certainty, art.2 (a) of the Regulation makes reference to Point A of Article 3 of ILO Convention on the Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention'.
Require companies to support labour inspection services and other services responsible for the implementation of legislation aimed at abolition of forced or compulsory labour.
The entity supports evidence-based, risk-based investigations in general terms, but explicitly asks the Commission to raise the evidentiary bar for accepting complaints and to discard allegations that cannot establish a specific product link, which functions as raising the threshold for who can trigger an investigation.
The document indicates that 'It is recommended that the European Commission only accept information when it contains objective and verifiable supporting evidence and sufficiently precise information to localise the issue reported. Any information on alleged violations should be discarded under Article 9.3 if a link with the product cannot be established.'
The entity supports the risk-based enforcement approach and the risk database in principle, but repeatedly pushes to narrow/clarify the scope of information operators must provide and to raise evidentiary thresholds for complaints, especially for smallholder-dominated sectors.
The paper states that 'The extent of information to be provided during an investigation to competent authorities under Article 5(3) will need to be clarified, specifically in the case of agricultural sectors composed of millions of smallholder farmers.' Also, 'the legislation should ensure that these provisions are accompanied with clear requirements on substantiated evidence and control mechanisms, so that they do not expose competent authorities and companies to excessive investigations.' Finally, 'operators with due diligence systems recognised as sufficiently effective by competent authorities should be classified as low risk and treated accordingly'.
Require companies to promote and support initiatives that identify, protect, recover, rehabilitate, and empower victims and those at risk, regardless of their presence and legal status, including through access to remedy.
The document proposes a remediation and victim-protection framework that goes beyond the FLR's own scope on this indicator.
The document calls for 'Restitution to ensure that workers are paid any owed wages ... Rehabilitation that could include provisions such as stipends, legal assistance, and assistance with repatriation ... Medical care, psychological support ... Compensation for pain and suffering endured.' It also states that 'Companies sourcing from the same geographic area are encouraged to set up a remediation fund.' It adds 'disengagement from suppliers should be treated as a last resort, only after meaningful remediation efforts ... companies should consider working with the cooperatives to potentially exclude only the individual farmers found to be using forced labour.'
Implementing an enforcement mechanism where companies fail to implement measures to combat forced labour.
Although the document accepts that enforcement decisions exist, it repeatedly asks to narrow their scope and soften their consequences. It asks authorities not to open formal investigations once a remediation process has started.
The document states that 'It would be recommended that the decision be limited to only those products where a direct link can be established. In such events, the lead competent authorities should treat food products such as cocoa and chocolate as strategic or of critical importance to the Union, meaning that the products should be withheld rather than disposed of.' Also, 'Once a remediation process has been initiated, lead competent authorities are encouraged not to open an investigation under Article 18.' Finally, 'the withdrawal and/or disposal of products should be avoided at all times.'
The entity welcomes that the burden of proof rests with competent authorities but also pushes to narrow the scope and conditions of enforcement decisions and customs suspension powers, which can be considered as an attempt to reduce competent authorities' powers.
The paper indicates that ECA 'welcomes the fact that the Regulation in its recitals (recital 26) explicitly places the burden of proof on the competent authorities ... However, for legal certainty, such fundamental principles should also be made explicit in the text of the Regulation itself.' In addition, 'the decisions ... taken by competent authorities under Article 6, should apply exclusively to a specific shipment and operator, and only in the event of actual and verified cases of forced labour.' It also points out that 'this suspension should only be applied in case of well-motivated serious and specific concerns related to a specific shipment of products.'
| Legislation | Position |
|---|---|
| EU CSDDD | Neutral/Mixed |
| EU FLR | Neutral/Mixed |
| Member | Performance band |
|---|