Require the elimination of other distinction, exclusion or preference which has the effect of nullifying or impairing equality of opportunity or treatment in employment or occupation…” also includes other types of discrimination stemming from e.g., classification of workers as contractors vs employees.
The entity argues that platforms should be able to provide protections and trainings to self-employed workers without it impacting employment classification. This call would help to reduce unfair working conditions for platform workers, while also serving to reduce the requirements for platforms to provide social protection to their workers.
"the Commission’s proposals- and an ill-defined rebuttable presumption of employment in particular- risk failing to achieve these goals and generating outcomes that do not reflect what riders want.... The provisions designed to enable greater benefits and protections for those confirmed self-employed are insufficient.""We would like to see the clause which states that offering insurances, training measures and similar benefits would not be considered a determinant of an employment relationship strengthened by including it in a standalone Article. Platforms are unable to directly provide certain benefits to self-employed workers without legal risk to self-employed workers’ status. Recital 23 states that this should change, which is something Deliveroo has long argued for. Having this stated clearly in a standalone article would strengthen this point. This would help to ensure that those that are genuinely self-employed can benefit from increased protections thereby improving the working conditions in line with the goals of the proposals."
Require companies to establish a mechanism for determining the employment status of digital platform workers, and ensure digital platform workers have access to the fundamental rights in national law and international labour standards.
While the entity states its support for the EU's initiative to improve platform workers' working conditions, it expresses its concerns with the rebuttable presumption of employment and legal uncertainty around the classification criteria. It requests further clarity around how the EU's approach would work with national criteria, proposes suggestions on the criteria threshold, and warns against adverse impacts for individuals who are genuinely self-employed and wish to remain so.
"We support efforts to bring greater clarity to the definitions of employment and self-employment. We equally support the Commission’s objectives of improving platform workers’ working conditions and promoting the sustainable growth of digital labour platforms in the EU. However, the Commission’s proposals- and an ill-defined rebuttable presumption of employment in particular- risk failing to achieve these goals and generating outcomes that do not reflect what riders want. The primary issues with the proposals are: ○ The criteria triggering the presumption are not sufficiently clear to offer legal certainty and there remains a focus on reclassification. ○ The provisions designed to enable greater benefits and protections for those confirmed self-employed are insufficient. The rebuttable presumption of employment is not the solution to the challenges the sector faces.""The Commission’s proposals, focusing on facilitating reclassification, will not deliver flexibility, security or strong earnings for riders and it is expressly not what they want... The self-employed model allows riders to log in and out when they like and to accept and reject offers as they like (with no repercussions for rejecting offers). However, an employment model would mean working set shifts set by the employer, performance management and riders having to work exclusively with one platform. ... The broad nature of the criteria which trigger the presumption risks creating huge legal uncertainty. Riders and platforms will have little certainty about when it would and wouldn’t be applied, particularly as it risks being interpreted differently by different authorities and different Member States." ... requiring meeting three rather than two criteria to trigger the presumption would more robustly establish a possible employment relationship and reduce the likelihood of very divergent outcomes on the basis of different interpretations of the text by various authorities and Member States (Article 4.2). It would also help avoid lengthy legal challenges to rebut a presumption of employment which had been triggered where rulings on domestic definitions of employment/self-employment had already taken place."
The undersigned entities criticise the focus of the EU legislators on the classification of platform workers regarding their employment status.
While employment brings more social protections, it also brings rigidity in working patterns and loss of control. For people offering their services on platforms, flexibility and control have always been the primary attractions and we have long advocated for rules that provide couriers with the benefits and protections they deserve alongside the independence they want. The solution lies in protecting the flexibility of genuine self-employment while encouraging measures that improve working conditions in a manner that is compatible with on-demand work. However, the platform work directive focuses almost exclusively on who is an employee and who is not and does little to improve the rights of the self-employed. Ministers should take the time to get this right and not sacrifice the chance to improve the situation for the sake of a quick agreement. The European Union has a once in a generation opportunity to create a progressive self employment framework where platform workers enjoy the flexibility they want and the social protections they deserve. We urge them to take it.
Require companies to be transparent about the use of algorithmic decision-making affecting working conditions and access to work and ensure appropriate human oversight, and to guarantee platform workers’ effective rights to information and to review automated decisions.
The entity supports the EU implementing measures around algorithmic transparency and risk management, but calls for protections around commercially sensitive information and longer response times when platforms are requested to review decisions made by an algorithm.
"We are broadly supportive of the measures relating to algorithmic transparency as we believe it is important to explain to riders, in an understandable way, how our algorithms function and already do so through our rider information sites. We believe that these transparency obligations should include protections of trade secrets and commercially sensitive information in addition to preventing any requirements to share information which would allow the deception of consumers or harm to them through manipulation of the system (as is provided for in Article 5.6 of the EU Platforms to Business Regulation (Chapter IV). We also believe that the one week timeline for response to a request for review of a decision should be extended. This kind of request would require identification of the rider to begin, plus cross functional coordination (data protection, legal, operations) from both head office and the market in question, and would likely require highly individualised responses. Responses under GDPR are required within one month, which would seem more appropriate."
| Legislation | Position |
|---|---|
| EU PWD | Not Supporting |
| Trade Association | Performance band |
|---|