Making human rights due diligence a legal requirement for companies including systems to identify, assess, mitigate or manage human rights risks and impacts to improve that process over time and to disclose the risks and impacts, the steps taken and the results.
The entity rejects the CSDDD in its 2024 form, they call for the recognition of existing industry standards and for individual member states to fulfil their human rights duties.
"An EU supply chain due diligence directive, as now planned, would result in a new dimension of bureaucratic overload and legal uncertainty. It makes foreign trade more difficult and is at the expense of European jobs and value creation. CITHA therefore rejects the directive in its current form""Respecting human rights around the world is a goal to which the companies of CITHA's member organisations are also clearly committed. The UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights are decisive for European companies. They already base their global supply relationships on them and communicate European standards to the world via their international partners. However, placing European companies under general suspicion would prove counterproductive in practice, and the loss of economic substance in the EU would be further exacerbated by such a supply chain directive. CITHA therefore appeals: Instead of taking the route via the directive, let us make a new start together and consider in dialogue with each other how we can enforce our standards for the protection of human rights and the environment even more effectively across global supply chains worldwide.""Finally, the EU must also provide companies with better information on human rights risks in future. It should recognise existing industry standards. The primary goal of the supply chain law must not be to withdraw, but to empower companies. The EU member states must fulfil their very own state duty to protect human rights as part of their foreign policy and advocate for improved human rights standards within the framework of international agreements."
Requiring Human rights due diligence of all companies, regardless of sector and size, while still reflecting their individual circumstances..
The entity calls for the CSDDD to take into account the fewer opportunities SMEs have to influence supply chains
"A European regulation must take into account the fact that small and mediumsized enterprises have fewer opportunities to influence supply chains due to limited resources and less market power."
Enabling judicial enforcement with liability and compensation in case of harm caused by not fulfilling the due diligence obligations.
The entity criticises the proposed civil liability provision, citing more administrative costs and legal uncertainty
"The proposed civil liability must also be criticised. It is simply impractical to demand that companies from EU member states should be liable for breaches of duty that occur in their supply chains - and worldwide at that. While nongovernmental organisations are to benefit from their own rights of action, companies may be subject to additional evidentiary requirements. In this way, the often incalculable liability risks could lead to companies withdrawing from affected regions. A new litigation industry would emerge, leading to more administrative costs for companies. Uncertainty in foreign trade would increase."
Require companies to implement a due diligence process covering their value chain to identify, prevent, mitigate and remediate human rights impacts and improve that practice over time.
The entity calls for legal requirements to be limited to direct suppliers, stating that the cost of compliance would be too much. They also call for exemptions for suppliers and customers based in the EU internal market.
"CITHA therefore rejects the directive in its current form. This applies in particular to three aspects of the directive Companies should therefore monitor almost all stages of their supply chains globally for violations of human rights and environmental or social standards. Industrial companies in particular often have tens of thousands or even a six-figure number of suppliers, a considerable proportion of which change every year. The costs of compliance alone would often run into the millions for individual companies. The directive does not make any clear exceptions - not even for supply relationships within the already heavily regulated EU internal market. However, an explicit exemption for all suppliers and customers based in the EU internal market would be urgently required as part of a risk-based approach. According to the EU plans, not only suppliers and their suppliers are to be monitored, but also business customers. However, it is a completely unrealistic assumption that SMEs could dictate to their business customers how and where the products they sell are ultimately used.""The scope of application across the entire value chain - including within Europe and at downstream stages - is unrealistic. Mandatory legal requirements must be limited to direct suppliers in order to be realisable in day-to-day practice."
Require companies to set requirements relevant to the prevention of forced or compulsory labour applicable to all workers and all sectors of the economy.
The entity expresses concerns over harmonisation with other legislations, the timeframe for the "ban" to be implemented, and the increased cost and lack of resources for SMEs. They call for the publication of guidelines to be done 12 months from the entry into force of the regulation and for a reporting obligation for member states on the application of the law.
"The Commission proposal is another EU human rights legal instrument, such as the Value Chain Directive (CSDD), the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) or the Conflict Minerals Regulation. However, there are overlaps between these legal provisions, which result in a bureaucratic multiple burden for companies. Due to the multitude of regulations, the desired harmonisation within the internal market is not achieved.""We have major concerns about the timeframe in which the ban is to be implemented. The draft needs to be adapted by the legislator to ensure a smooth implementation.""Even though article 4.2 mentions “… take into account the size and economic resources of the economic operators … “ the proposed regulation does not include any provision to mitigate the increased cost of compliance for SMEs. Moreover, it does not explicitly give any indication about the “size” nor the “economic resources”, thus it introduces uncertainty. Would very small companies be entitled to special treatment? Article 4.6 establishes that relevant authorities should take into account if the economic operator has carried out due diligence. This clause calls for discrimination (i.e. privileged treatment) in favour of big companies because they do have resources to carry out due diligence, while SMEs would not normally have enough resources to do it on a regular basis. It is not clear how far back the due diligence has to go. Global value chains and the level of globalization that has been achieved, makes it very normal that the production process of a product takes place in several countries by several economic operators in said countries. Big companies may have resources to carry out due diligence, but not small companies.""Article 23 of the draft regulation provides that the Commission shall, no later than 18 months after the entry into force of the Regulation ... Since the regulation applies two years after it enters into force, it is of great importance that this publication deadline is actually met so that the economy can prepare itself accordingly. A period of 12 months instead of 18 months would be desirable. Specifically, the guidelines are expected to include a structure and process that provides a comprehensive pathway for companies to comply with the ban on forced labour.""In practice, maximum harmonisation of the application of the law is of central importance with regard to the ""level playing field"" within the EU. With a regulation, the Commission has chosen the appropriate legal instrument to implement the desired effect in a comprehensive and practicable manner throughout the European Union. Against this backdrop, it would be welcome if the regulation, within the framework of the final provisions, would establish a regular (e.g., 2-year) reporting obligation of the Commission on the application of the regulation in the individual member states. This should include a detailed evaluation of the application of the law in the individual member states. Throughout the proposed regulation it is mentioned that it is important to preserve the EU common market and a fair playing field. However, as monitoring and implementation of the proposed regulation is assigned to individual member states, there surely can exist many disparities in the practical requirements and monitoring for compliance and in the cost of non-compliance."
Require companies to support labour inspection services and other services responsible for the implementation of legislation aimed at abolition of forced or compulsory labour.
The entity raises concerns about the lack of timelines around investigations, both in terms of the period between the initiation and the date of request for information and the maximum duration of an investigation. They call for competent authorities to be fully operational from the date of entry into force of the regulation.
"There is no time limit set for the competent authorities for the period from the initiation of the preliminary investigation to the date of the request for information by the economic operators concerned (Article 4). This clearly stands out negatively in direct contrast to the clear time limits in Article 8. There is no specific time limit for the maximum duration of an investigation by the competent authorities (Art. 6). In Article 6 (1) there is only the requirement of a "reasonable time". Missing or vague deadlines create the risk that decisions could be delayed for an unacceptably long time. This would also create competition-distorting handling in the member states and could, for example, detain goods indefinitely in customs or at the port.""From the date of entry into force of the regulation, the competent authorities should be operational. The competent authority must also have sufficient institutional financial and material resources to implement the prohibition of forced labour."
Implementing an enforcement mechanism where companies fail to implement measures to combat forced labour.
The entity calls for the implementation of the regulation in terms of product withdrawal should lie with member states, citing the cost for SMEs. They also call for a uniform framework to be created with regard to penalties which goes beyond the general requirements set out. Lastly, they call for customs authorities to cooperate with competent authorities.
"According to Article 6 (paragraph 4), the practical implementation of a traffic and export ban is the sole responsibility of the companies concerned. This can be very demanding, especially for SMEs. Withdrawing products from the market can be a very expensive task which SMEs, especially small companies, do not have the resources to carry it out. Moreover, a compulsory take out/withdrawal of the market of non-compliant products may be so high in terms of overall turnover of an SME that it might result in the bankruptcy of said SME. Therefore, the responsibility for implementation should lie with the member states. Article 30 also provides for sanctions to be determined by the individual member states. If this cannot be legally established in a uniform way in the European regulation, at least a uniform framework should be set that goes beyond the general requirements in Art. 30 paragraph 2 "effective, proportionate and dissuasive". Member states may establish penalties which greatly differ in economic terms, thus making non-compliance much more expensive in some Member States than in others. Similarly, this article requires Member States to “take all measures necessary to ensure that they are implemented …” Available resources of Member States to ensure compliance may vary significantly, thus penalizing economic operators of countries which do allocate abundant resources to this end.""Customs authorities act at the external borders of the EU on the basis of decisions taken by the competent authorities of the Member States. This can be a serious weakness. Companies have repeatedly experienced unfair practices between the different customs authorities of the member countries that lead to competitive disadvantages for companies from other countries. The absolute necessity of a compliant implementation of the regulation in the different member countries should be emphasised. Customs authorities should cooperate with the competent authorities and not in addition to them. By the time businesses have to comply with the Regulation, accessibility and data processing should be operational. The mere naming of the customs authority (Art. 2; Art. 15) is not sufficient. It is necessary that companies and stakeholders are given the opportunity to have official decisions reviewed by the courts."
| Legislation | Position |
|---|---|
| EU CSDDD | Not Supporting |
| EU FLR | Not Supporting |
| Member | Performance band |
|---|