Making human rights due diligence a legal requirement for companies including systems to identify, assess, mitigate or manage human rights risks and impacts to improve that process over time and to disclose the risks and impacts, the steps taken and the results.
The entity calls for a risk based approach to due diligence obligations
"Our understanding is that the Omnibus Package is intended to introduce regulatory simplification measures without losing sight of our shared environmental and social goals. To that end, we submit the following comments .... Additionally, due diligence is ultimately enabled through leverage with business partners. Where there is no leverage, there can be no influence to change environmental or social business practices, which is well supported by both OECD Guidelines and the UNGPs. We call, therefore, for a risk-based approach to due diligence obligations, which empowers industry actors to address the most pressing social and environmental risks where they have the leverage to do so."
Requiring Human rights due diligence of all companies, regardless of sector and size, while still reflecting their individual circumstances..
The entity warns against overly narrow scope for companies and stresses the need for a shared standard of due diligence obligations
"Further, to be successful, due diligence has to be implemented across all sellers entering goods into the EU market. Although AAFA is supportive of the EU’s efforts to safeguard the interests of Small and Medium Enterprises (SME), we caution against over-narrowing the scope of companies required to conduct due diligence across their chain of activities. Over-large employee and global turnover thresholds risk obviating the purpose of regulation to the point of obsolescence. While there is perhaps no magic number that most effectively maximizes both supply chain influence and the protection of SME interests, we believe that it is important that the final Omnibus Package maintain a shared standard of due diligence across sellers that adequately improves labor-centered and environmental outcomes."
Require companies to implement a due diligence process covering their value chain to identify, prevent, mitigate and remediate human rights impacts and improve that practice over time.
The entity critiques the value chain cap citing it renders the intention of the CSDDD impotent but also emphasises that responsibilities lie with direct suppliers and a business relationship does not de facto contribute to human rights impacts
"Under both the OECD Guidelines and the UNGPs, buyers are not responsible for addressing human rights and environmental risks linked to their suppliers’ suppliers that are not in the direct supply chain. Brands are only responsible for sub-suppliers that actually produce their goods, or the materials that go into their goods. As the Omnibus Package continues to be refined, thereby finalizing the scope of required due diligence under CSDDD, we ask that EU co-legislators keep in mind that simply having a business relationship is not the same as contributing to human rights or environmental impact.""We also ask that companies be allowed to collect required information from across their supply chains. We believe that the proposed Value Chain Cap is short-sighted given that much of the necessary data required for effective due diligence is held by suppliers operating below the proposed cap. A strict cap on information gathering is an active hinderance for transparency and renders impotent the original intentions of the Directives."
Require companies to set requirements relevant to the prevention of forced or compulsory labour applicable to all workers and all sectors of the economy.
The entity recognises economic operators responsibility and role in eliminating forced labour, and calls for the FLR to be designed and implemented in a way that is transparent, is based in information exchange, and aligns with international definitions and standards of forced labour and due diligence.
"Strong regulation enables responsible industry actors to make good on their promises of effective social due diligence, however it is of paramount importance that the regulation on forced labor be founded on a system of transparency, where information is shared by both regulators and the regulated. Ultimately, our membership is heavily invested in finding and removing forced labor from the supply chain, and shares regulators’ goals of putting an end to forced labor wherever it exists. As the EU hones its approach to implementing the FLR, it is our sincere hope that regulators share with industry any allegations of forced labor in supply chains so that industry actors can be a part of the collective eradication of forced labor""It is critical that definitions of forced labor or due diligence not be redefined. These are widely understood concepts under international standards, including the ILO Forced Labor Protocol, ILO Indicators of Forced Labor, OECD’s Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises, and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. In addition, numerous IGO, industry, and multi-stakeholder guidance documents already exist to support companies’ actions to undertake due diligence and seek to address forced labor. To the extent that the EU creates supplemental guidance, it should be demand driven, fill a noted gap, and focus on the administrative requirements of compliance with the FLR."
The singed entities do not take an explicit position on the EU's FLR, but state that any regulation should be aligned with international human rights standards. However, they also call for the recognition of and collaboration with voluntary industry schemes and social audits.
"Our associations, and the companies we represent, do not tolerate the use of forced labor or other human rights abuses within our supply chains. ... As the European Commission considers whether, and how, to move forward on some form of an EU forced labor statute, we offer our learnings and experience with the U.S. forced labor statute to inform its deliberations. First and foremost, we believe an effective forced labor statute must provide space for the government to partner with good actors and target bad actors. This requires mechanisms to allow for information sharing with industry and the development of best practices and a transparent process for enforcement. ... Further, any proposal should align with internationally-accepted and widely-endorsed principles including the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights and the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises. ... , any legislative initiative should benefit from and work hand-in-hand with voluntary, collaborative initiatives that in some cases have worked for decades to help business identify, prevent, and remediate forced labor. To that end, social compliance audits, when conducted by qualified auditors against strong protocols, often identify instances or indicators of forced labor and have led to the resolution of hundreds of thousands instances of forced labor. Social compliance audits – again, where they can be conducted credibly – should remain a strong accepted tool for assessing the potential for forced labor."
Require companies to support labour inspection services and other services responsible for the implementation of legislation aimed at abolition of forced or compulsory labour.
The entity calls for technological support and consistent standards for company due diligence compliance, while outlining that limitations to supply chain mapping should be taken into consideration.
"Companies are increasingly leveraging technological solutions to supply chain due diligence. While we would not recommend endorsing a specific technology, we would ask that the EU establish a common set of standards that would enable importers to vet potential solution providers and ensure consistency in their approaches to due diligence compliance.""While we share the goal of ending forced labor, and have seen first-hand the benefits of how importers’ leverage can be used to identify and remedy instances of forced labor, our members also continually experience the limits of their visibility and leverage. SMEs may lack the resources or know-how to trace their supply chains, MNEs may be confronting a supply chain of hundreds of thousands of entities, conflict zones may prevent access to sites, and state-based national priorities may conflict with the EU’s stated goals. There is a limit to what importers can know about the many tiers of their supply chain and there is often even less leverage for them to affect a remedy."
The signed entities call for regulators to work with economic operators to help design and implement tools aimed at the detection of goods and products produced with forced labour.
"Finally, there have been many discussions in the United States about employing new technologies to better track and trace products and ensure goods made with forced labor do not enter the U.S. market. These technologies could be further advanced if government partnered with industry to share information and to test the reliability, scalability, and accuracy of these tools in preventing products made with forced labor from entering the U.S. market."
Implementing an enforcement mechanism where companies fail to implement measures to combat forced labour.
The entity supports the enforcement of the FLR and banning of products determined to be produced with forced labour. Based on US import ban learnings, the entity calls for a risk-based approach to enforcement, transparent information sharing on why imports are detained in order to rebut or provide remedy, and for there to be a standardised and consistent approach to enforcement and review so that economic operators can adapt and better identify risks and violations.
"The EU will invariably need to take a risk-based approach to enforcement. Such risk determinations should be based upon widely available, credible, and verifiable information. If the EU is to consider identifying priority sectors for the purpose of FLR enforcement, we ask that those priorities be shared with industry stakeholders.""we ask that FLR's enforcement system be implemented transparently such that information is readily shared with industry partners, and particularly with trusted traders, to more effectively target high-risk shipments and improve resource efficiency across EU borders. This information should include the suspected nexuses to forced labor that led EU officials to detain shipments so that industry partners are well positioned to either rebut the presumption of forced labor, and thereby secure a release of the held shipments, or remedy the issue. Responsible industry actors can do little to remedy issues of which they have no knowledge and so, in furtherance of the eradication of forced labor, allegations of forced labor must be transparently shared. ... It is vital that the EU avoids creating a black box enforcement mechanism where shipments are detained but no explanation is offered. Such an approach benefits neither business nor improves working conditions.""The implementation of the FLR must include a standardized framework for economic operators to demonstrate that their goods were not made in whole or in part through forced labor in the case of a detained shipment. In the context of UFLPA, this is called an “Applicability Review”. For situations where goods detained under the FLR are from a supplier not on the entity list, regulators should clarify the supply chain evidence needed to clear suppliers from further regulatory scrutiny and detention activity. In pursuit of such a standard, we recommend accepting a ‘minimum number of shipments released with no forced labor findings’ threshold to prevent good supply chain actors from being continuously targeted .... When EU regulators add entities to an entity list, or otherwise detain a shipment, based on NGO and academic reports, we ask for a defined process for verifying the credibility of such reports.""In the U.S., importers have noticed discrepancies in how certain ports detain shipments. In ensuring consistent treatment of shipments across the EU market, we ask that training be provided across competent national authorities in EU member states and that EU officials establish a review process for enforcement consistency."
The entity supports the banning of products that are determined to be produced using forced labour, while calling for clear and transparent communication of violations and inspection outcomes to economic operators in order to improve effective enforcement and better prevent forced labour in the future.
"Under the U.S. forced labor statute, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), the U.S. government implementing agency, can choose to ban U.S. imports of specific products from specific suppliers in specific countries... or can ban U.S. imports of certain products from an entire region or country... However, when CBP issues a so-called withhold release order (WRO), it does not release any of the evidence supporting the WRO, nor the text of the WRO itself. Understanding what information led to the WRO’s issuance would be incredibly useful to industry to incorporate into its own due diligence. This, in turn, would amplify enforcement efforts to stop products made with forced labor from entering the U.S. market.""Further, when CBP detains merchandise under a WRO, importers are not provided details in detention notices regarding the type of product, country of origin, or supplier that triggered the detention, or even which ILO forced labor indicators were allegedly violated. ... , having a mechanism that would enable the sharing of this information would give importers the ability to incorporate the information into their future due diligence and amplify enforcement going forward.""Just as important, the “evidence” for a detention must be based on more than just “open source” NGO/press reports. That “open source” information can lead to an investigation, but more evidence should be needed for an actual detention."
| Legislation | Position |
|---|---|
| EU FLR | Neutral/Mixed |
| Omnibus | Neutral/Mixed |