Making human rights due diligence a legal requirement for companies including systems to identify, assess, mitigate or manage human rights risks and impacts to improve that process over time and to disclose the risks and impacts, the steps taken and the results.
The entity supports the CSDDD but critiques the directive for its lack of harmonisation
"The compromise agreement reached by EU institutions in December 2023 reflects a high level of alignment with existing internationally recognised human rights and environment due diligence standards, which AIM is committed to promoting through our AIM-Progress responsible sourcing initiative. The compromise agreement rightly requires companies to take a risk-based approach to their due diligence, allowing them to prioritise their actions and focus on actions that will have the greatest impact. The Directive falls however short of providing a set of fully harmonised due diligence rules at EU level. We call therefore on EU member states to harness the opportunity which the further transposition process offers to ensure as much EU-wide harmonisation as possible of their national due diligence rules. This is essential to avoid diverging national rules which would inevitably lead to fragmentation of the EU internal market. “Industry needs legal certainty and clarity, and it is important that we deflect the risk of internal market fragmentation, resulting from uncoordinated national transposition of the EU due diligence rules” observed Michelle Gibbons, Director-General of AIM"
The entity supports the proposal for the CSDD but critiques the minimum harmonisation approach taken
"AIM is pleased that the European Commission has finally put forward a proposal for a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence. This is a unique opportunity to set common legal requirements across the EU and ensure legal certainty and the smooth functioning of the internal market. ... The EU Commission is effectively looking at a minimum harmonisation approach, leaving room for Member States to impose varying obligations on companies. This is bound to lead to a divergence of rules at national level, undermining legal certainty and increasing risk of internal market fragmentation. It can also open the door to ‘forum shopping’ by companies in terms of establishment of their operations in the EU."
The entity supports the EU for enacting a human rights due diligence legislation
"Brand manufacturers praise the EU for enacting laws to enhance #HumanRights and #environmental standards in #supplychains: the #EUForcedLabourRegulation and #CSDDD. We urge the @EU_Commission to quickly release guidelines to help businesses comply."
The entity is supportive of a legislative framework for human rights due diligence and call for the CSDDD to be harmonised across member states and for alignment with the CSRD. They ask for clarity on definition and scope on what constitutes severe human rights harms for guidance on the fitness of industry schemes. They also call for the possibility for reporting at group level and for a minimum standard to be set for bringing forward complaints.
"AIM – the European Brands Association – is supportive of an EU harmonised legislative framework for human rights and environmental due diligence. ... adopt a maximum harmonisation approach to the due diligence obligations set out in the proposed Directive to avoid fragmentation of requirements between Member States’ national regimes, as well as to ensure legal certainty and a level playing field for companies operating across the EU single market; reframe the scope of the due diligence obligations in the proposed Directive to allow companies to prioritise their efforts based on the severity of actual or potential adverse impacts;""define what constitutes a “severe human rights and environmental harm” in an interpretative guidance, following constructive dialogue amongst all relevant stakeholders, and taking into account already existing instruments or standards;""align the content and format of the reporting with regards to due diligence in the proposed Directive with those required by the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, and provide the possibility forcompanies to refer to global consolidated reporting at group level; set minimum requirements for natural and legal persons to be entitled to bring administrative or legal complaints based on a strict “direct interest in acting” standard with a view to preventing frivolous or abusive complaints and lawsuits; require the issuance of guidance for assessing the fitness of industry schemes and multi-stakeholder initiatives as part of a company’s overall due diligence approach with a view to ensuring effective due diligence;"
Requiring Human rights due diligence of all companies, regardless of sector and size, while still reflecting their individual circumstances..
The entity supports the application of the legislation of the application regardless of sector/size and critiques the exclusion of SMEs
"It is also an opportunity to ensure a level playing field, impressing on businesses, whether large or small and regardless of which commodity sector they operate in, that respect of human rights and protection of the environment is a licence to operate and that scrutiny of operations will only increase. ... With regards to providing a level playing field, AIM welcomes the horizontal nature of the proposal and its application to all sectors and commodities to provide a common framework for the entire business community. We believe this approach can be complemented by vertical legislation addressing specificities of relevant sectors and commodities. However, the exemption of SMEs will cause numerous practical challenges for those businesses, given any of them who operate within global supply chains, will naturally be included in the standards followed by other operators in those supply chains. The exemption, in our view, is a lost opportunity to set out clearly that the means through which a business is expected to meet this responsibility should be proportional to its size and to the risk of being involved with severe human rights impacts. Furthermore, support mechanisms can be put in place specifically for SMEs."
Including in the duties of directors and company law obligations to avoid human rights impacts or “harms”.
The entity calls for further clarity on directors duty of care
"ensure legal certainty by providing further clarity on the interaction between directors’ duty of care (Article 25) and responsibility for setting up and overseeing due diligence (Article 26), as well as giving flexibility to companies as to which level the directors’ duties shall apply;"
Enabling judicial enforcement with liability and compensation in case of harm caused by not fulfilling the due diligence obligations.
The entity calls for resolution around the ambiguity of the civil liability provision citing heightened company risk to litigation
"resolve the ambiguity of the civil liability provision in the proposed Directive, which is based on unclear definitions and sets a scope of liability that exposes companies to heightened legal risks for harms beyond their control, potentially leading them to focus more on managing the risk of litigation rather than carrying out robust due diligence;"
Require that human rights risks and impacts should be assessed through dialogue with stakeholder or with their legitimate representatives.
The entity calls for guidance around pro-active engagement with stakeholders
"require the issuance of detailed guidance regarding pro-active engagement with affected or potentially affected stakeholders at key moments in a company’s due diligence process clarifying that this complements reactive engagement with affected or potentially affected stakeholders through complaints procedures."
Require companies to set requirements relevant to the prevention of forced or compulsory labour applicable to all workers and all sectors of the economy.
The entity supports the objectives of the FLR stating a need for alignment with the, at the time, upcoming CSDDD as well alignment with ILO forced labour indicators. The entity calls for an impact assessment to be conducted and for the implementation of harmonised guidelines at the time of entry into forced, however the entity calls for the responsibility of compliance to lie with the first importer of a product/commodity on the EU market rather than companies further in the supply chain.
"AIM, the European Brands Association, is supportive of the EU Commission’s objective to root out forced labour from supply chains. We thus welcome the Commission's intent to address the issue of products made with forced labour.""Any complementary vertical EU legislation, including market access regulation for products made with forced labour, should be aligned with the future Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence in order to ensure legal certainty and a level playing field for companies""Any EU instrument on forced labour should align with international standards, in particular the ILO forced labour indicators when it comes to the determination of whether forced labour has been used.""the European Commission’s consultation process should include an appropriate assessment of the instrument’s potential to ensure it achieves long-term positive impacts for vulnerable individuals and communities.""implementation guidance for companies is absolutely key. Whether the upcoming EU legislation requires an upfront due diligence statement ... or an ex-post rebuttal of a presumption of non-compliance by the importer ..., it is important to provide businesses with implementation guidance clarifying the expected steps for due diligence necessary to comply with the new EU rules. Such implementation guidance should be harmonized at EU level to avoid divergent requirements across EU Member States, which would otherwise lead to legal uncertainty, additional costs and increased administrative burden for companies striving to comply with the new EU rules. Adopting an EU legislative framework without developing and making available such implementation guidance at the time of entry into force would be problematic for both operators and enforcement authorities.""AIM calls on the EU to play an active role in engaging with non-EU countries and stakeholders on issues related to the new legislation, with a view to establishing long-term partnership agreements with the governments of third countries and involving relevant stakeholders. These partnership agreements should include time-bound frameworks for action for all parties involved, placing a particular emphasis on actions at the policy level by producer governments as well as other relevant stakeholders, and include incentive mechanisms and support from the EU and its member states to ensure that the necessary actions can be implemented successfully.""it is key to clearly identify the operator with whom responsibility for compliance lies. AIM argues that this responsibility should lie with the first importer of a product/commodity on the EU market, who should make available any relevant due diligence information to subsequent operators and traders in the supply chain and therefore avoid duplication of efforts and compliance costs."
The entity supports the FLR's approach to focusing on individual instances of forced labour rather than a regional ban, calling for the EU and member states to exert leverage with partner country governments. They specifically note the need to take into account compliance with the CSDDD and the need for guidelines to be aligned with the CSDDD. They also call for an extension of the application for member states by half a year, for products with negligible risk to be taken into account as a mitigation factor for companies and for the responsibility for compliance to lie with the first importer of a product or commodity
"Therefore, to ensure coherence between the two EU legal instruments, a company’s compliance with its due diligence obligation foreseen under the EU Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence should be taken into account by competent authorities in carrying out their investigation and enforcement obligations as per the EU Regulation. Given the importance of EU-wide due diligence legislation being in place to enable companies to demonstrate compliance, AIM urges the Commission to ensure that the timing of the entry into force and application of the EU Regulation on forced labour is parallel or consecutive to the entry into force and application of the proposed Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence. This will ensure legal certainty and a level playing field for companies, allowing them to set up their due diligence processes."" Article 23 of the proposed EU Regulation, the Commission provides for the issuance of necessary guidelines by 18 months after the entry into force of the regulation. The application date for the regulation at Member State level is 24 months after entry into force of the regulation. AIM members remain concerned that despite the 6 months gap, the guidelines may not be fully understood and implemented by competent authorities in EU Member States at the time of application of the EU Regulation at national level; but more importantly that there remains a risk of divergent interpretation of how to assess forced labour risks across the EU. ... AIM would therefore advocate allowing for a 12-month adaptation period for Member States, which would mean that the date of application of the EU Regulation should intervene 2.5 years (instead of 2 years) after its entry into force.""AIM strongly welcomes the fact that the Commission proposes to build on existing relevant guidance already published in July 2021. Such additional guidance should be foreseen in Article 23 of the EU Regulation and clarify the expected steps for due diligence necessary to comply with the new EU rules. The guidance should be harmonised at EU level to avoid divergent requirements across EU Member States, which would otherwise lead to legal uncertainty and increased administrative burden for companies striving to comply with the new EU rules. ... this guidance should be coherent with relevant guidance provided for in the proposed Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence and Regulation on Deforestation-Free Products.""Given the risk-based prioritisation of severe adverse impacts, this could lead to products being imported where a negligible risk of forced labour is present, while the company continues to mitigate and ultimately prevent the risk through continuous improvement. It remains unclear whether affected products would still be allowed on the EU market if companies would be able to prove only a negligible risk. AIM believes that the fact that areas or products are classified as entailing negligible risk in the database provided for in Article 11 of the proposed EU Regulation should be taken into account as a mitigation factor for companies, who should focus their due diligence efforts where risks are the highest. If risks are identified in a non-prioritised sector or supply chain, the EU Regulation should allow a reasonable timeframe to address them.""For ingredients sourced with a mass balance approach, which is a widely used practice in complex agriculture supply chains where commodities are supplied in bulk and mixed during shipping and manufacturing, risks of forced labour are more challenging to identify and address. Given the prevalence of mass balance for critical commodities, it is important to set clear guidance on how products with such ingredients should be handled under the new EU Regulation.""AIM supports the Commission’s approach of focusing on individual instances of forced labour. Applying the ban to a whole region or commodity sector when an instance of forced labour is discovered for a product in one part of that region or commodity sector should be resisted, to avoid unduly penalising responsible companies located in the same geographical area where no forced labour is occurring.""AIM calls on the EU and its Member States to exert direct leverage and support enabling environments by engaging with partner country governments whose role remains critical, as they implement their internationally recognised duties to protect and promote human rights. Partnership agreements should include time-bound frameworks for action for all parties involved to address forced labour, placing a particular emphasis on public policy by producer governments, and include incentive mechanisms and support from the EU and its Member States to ensure that the necessary actions can be implemented successfully.""AIM argues that this responsibility should lie with the first importer/placer of a product on the EU market or the exporter, who should show evidence, upon request by competent authorities while performing their investigation duties, that relevant due diligence has been carried out prior to placing the products on the EU market or exporting them. The current prohibition in Article 3 of the proposed EU Regulation also seems to apply to economic operators “making available” products on the EU market, thereby potentially duplicating compliance responsibility for both importers/exporters and other economic operators in the supply chain."
The signed entities support the prohibition of products produced with forced labour under the EU's proposal for a FLR.
"We, the undersigned organisations, welcome the objectives of the European Commission’s proposal for a Regulation (2022/0269 COD) on prohibiting products made with forced labour on the Union market, the so-called ‘EU Forced Labour Regulation’."
Require companies to support labour inspection services and other services responsible for the implementation of legislation aimed at abolition of forced or compulsory labour.
The entity calls for guidance to be provided to competent authorities on state imposed forced labour to feed into the database yet also supports the burden of proof lying with competent authorities
"AIM would also suggest that the guidance for competent authorities, provided for in Article 23 of the proposed EU Regulation, makes a clear distinction for risk evaluation between forced labour risks in the private sector and forced labour imposed by state authorities, as referenced in the Commission proposal, in order to feed into the database of forced labour risk areas and productsnforeseen in Article 13 of the proposed EU Regulation.""AIM supports the approach taken in the Commission proposal whereby competent authoritiesin EU Member States should carry the burden of proof to establish that forced labour has been used. Given the complexity of identiying instances of forced labour, multiple indicators and information sources will need to be used. In this regard, we also support that economic operators should have the opportunity to provide information in their defence to the competent authorities throughout the investigation”, as per Recital 26 of the proposed EU Regulation, and further detailed in Article 4. Although there are very exceptional situations that EU law provides for a reversal of the burden of proof, the forced labour regulation should not deviate from this foundational principle."
Require companies to promote and support initiatives that identify, protect, recover, rehabilitate, and empower victims and those at risk, regardless of their presence and legal status, including through access to remedy.
The signed entities call for there to be explicit remediation provisions in the EU's FLR to increase the effectiveness of the regulation, align with international human rights standards, and to support victims of forced labour. This call goes beyond the topics and questions of the FLR's consultations at the time, and shows support for stronger standard than that put forward by the EU itself.
"As Companies, Trade Unions, Civil Society Organisations, Certification Organisations and Multi stakeholder Initiatives, we stress the need to have clear and effective provisions on remediation in the EU Forced Labour Regulation. Remediation is a key step of human rights due diligence, as defined by the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs) and the OECD Due Diligence Guidance for Responsible Business Conduct (RBC). ... Including remediation and other appropriate measures in the EU Forced Labour Regulation would enhance the legislation’s effectiveness in eradicating forced labour from supply chains. Remediation provisions regarding forced labour are crucial for providing remedy to victims of forced labour. At the same time, they can support companies in building meaningful long-term relations with their suppliers to address and prevent forced labour risks in their operations and supply chains. Consequently, the EU Forced Labour Regulation should indicate the possibility for companies to take remedial actions depending on their involvement in an identified case of forced labour. These remedial actions should be aligned with the cause, contribution and linkage “involvement framework” set out in the UNGPs and OECD Due Diligence Guidance for RBC ... Competent authorities or the European Commission should be required to lift the withdrawal of the concerned products from the market if they establish that companies took action to remediate forced labour cases in line with the above-mentioned involvement framework."
Implementing an enforcement mechanism where companies fail to implement measures to combat forced labour.
The entity supports interconnected and coordinated decisions and calls for the establishment of a centralised enforcement authority at the EU level. The entity disagrees with the rules for penalties being left with individual member states and calls for a harmonised approach to penalties to avoid " forum shopping". They also call for the priotisation of state imposed forced labour in enforcement and call for suspension of a product to be maintained for a maximum of 8 days. However, the entity calls companies to be provided with compensation in the event of a wrongful decision
"Finally, AIM supports the creation of the interconnection for decisions (Article 22), as well as the EU network for coordination (Article 24) to ease the communication between national competent authorities, Member States, and the European Commission. This should work to ensure harmonised implementation and enforcement across the EU Single Market. AIM calls, however, for the establishment of a centralized enforcement authority at EU level, in order to avoid divergences in the implementation and enforcement of the EU Regulation between Member States.""Another point of concern for AIM is the fact that the laying down of rules on penalties applicable to noncompliance is left to EU Member States, in accordance with national law. We would advocate an EU harmonised approach to penalties to avoid “forum-shopping” by importers and exporters where penalties are the lowest. This could be achieved through clear guidelines laying down principles, such as proportionality, and through a monitoring mechanism implemented by the European Commission""In addition, Article 18(1)(1) of the proposed EU Regulation gives the authorities a right to maintain the suspension of a product beyond 4 initial days, whereas we believe that this provision should specify a maximum time (of 8 days) during which the authorities can maintain the suspension of the goods.""Competent authorities should prioritise forced labour imposed by state authorities as part of their risk-based enforcement of the EU Regulation.""AIM welcomes the remedies foreseen in the proposed EU Regulation enabling economic operators to contest decisions affecting them before competent authorities.""Although Article 8(5) of the proposed EU Regulation gives access to court reviews on both procedural and substantive grounds, companies that have been subject to wrongful decisions by competent authorities should be entitled to compensation or damages, taking into account the material costs and disruptions of the enforced prohibition/withdrawal/destruction of products for impacted operators."
| Legislation | Position |
|---|---|
| EU CSDDD | Neutral/Mixed |
| EU FLR | Neutral/Mixed |